sábado, 16 de julho de 2016
terça-feira, 12 de julho de 2016
Jorge Bolet plays Franck Prélude, aria et finale
Prelude
Clocking in at around 10 minutes, the very title Prelude seems a bit misleading. It is, in fact, a fully-fledged sonata movement, complete with developmental fugue (!), and is the largest in scale, texture, and density of any of the movements. The opening chordal theme, marked Allegro moderato e maestoso, is warm, lush, and (somehow not conflictingly), march-like. Here and throughout one hears organ textures aplenty—thick, chordal writing is standard, but it is always rich with counterpoint. Additionally, the formal proportions are quite clear—a cadential trill and pause will mark the appearance of the second, more pensive, theme, first framed in high register (here again the organ’s antiphonal facility is invoked, with soprano statements answered by mellower treble/bass statements). The first truly turbulent music will be seen prior to another clear break which precipitates the development, which itself begins with a dark, severe and jagged fugue subject (an unorthodox subject in octaves). This slow-burn fugue will reach a violent outcry, which is suddenly assuaged by the most luminous, cantabile melody, carried downward by a rippling undercurrent. The recapitulation is again framed clearly, and will arrive in a most sublime way at the coda (for those interested in harmony, one of the most beautiful and unexpected modulations occurs here, when Franck introduces by deft slight-of-hand, the Neapolitan key).
Aria
As its title suggests, this is a cantabile movement whose inspiration is most likely domestic/secular, but it often approximates in texture the Chorale movement of Franck’s other, more well-known work for piano (the Prelude, Chorale and Fugue). Things often occur in threes in Franck’s music, and this movement is a good example—after the improvisatory introduction, Franck gives three melodic cells; the first is child-like, simple, and seems to have the contour of a cradle song. The second is closely related, but intimates by its harmonic complexion more troubled inner impulses. The third melody is truly “Franckian”; the most chromatic, and with Wagnerian harmonies underneath. When each melody appears it is stated twice—once in the soprano and then in the bass—and throughout the movement this happens twice (for a total of six). Franck’s reliance on this scheme verges on dangerous—one further statement could weary the listener. In fact, it may be an intentional red herring—the very opening (and closing) melody, in high relief atop a swath of arpeggios, will prove to be a much more important component of the whole work (this is seen in Finale).
Finale
This is one of the truly virtuosic, exciting Romantic finales (and remains, along with its two preceding companions, undeservedly under-played). The opening chromatic rumble will be recognized as a counter-subject in the dark fugal development of the Prelude—here it is a theme in its own right, and one of malevolent intentions. Its harmonic twisting and side-stepping is nearly exhausting, and is only supplanted by the most heroic impulses of the second theme whose march-like chords reach the physical extremities of the keyboard. This theme will be framed again under a shimmering, joyful right hand just prior to the development. Franck’s love of cyclical music (if not clear from the Finale’s outset) is certainly obvious around the middle of the development—after the opening rumbling theme, the Aria’s childlike theme appears, almost celestial amidst a constellation of arpeggios. But it is the moment of the coda’s onset which is perhaps the most exhilarating cyclic achievement in the entire work—here, over a thundering torrent of octaves in the bass, the opening maestoso theme of the Prelude appears triumphantly. Immediately following is a passage of sublime beauty—Franck has wedded this theme (the Prelude’s opening) to the first theme of the Aria in an opalescent couching of arpeggios. This is at once recognized as the moment of complete cyclical consummation—all themes have been brought together. Listeners will be struck at the optimistic, patient way Franck achieves this; where the cyclical point of the Prelude, Chorale and Fugue is certainly on a more thunderous, epic scale, the one seen here is quietly understated, and is allowed to play out and deliquesce with a graceful tranquility.
Postado por
Carlos Nougué
às
23:01
0
comentários
Enviar por e-mailPostar no blog!Compartilhar no XCompartilhar no FacebookCompartilhar com o Pinterest
Jorge Bolet plays Franck Prélude Choral and Fugue
A melhor interpretação que já me foi dado ouvir desta peça; e Jorge Bolet, com efeito, parece estar em terreno próprio com a música de César Franck. Imprime-lhe limpidez e solenidade. Grande pianista, sem dúvida.
Ver também:
Ver também:
|
|
Postado por
Carlos Nougué
às
22:53
0
comentários
Enviar por e-mailPostar no blog!Compartilhar no XCompartilhar no FacebookCompartilhar com o Pinterest
Em homenagem a Chopin, o melhor de sua obra - The 21 Nocturnes (Claudio Arrau)
Mas, como diz o Abbé Jalowicki,
"sua morte foi o mais belo concerto de toda a sua vida".
The Death of Chopin – A morte católica de Chopin
Postado por
Carlos Nougué
às
16:48
0
comentários
Enviar por e-mailPostar no blog!Compartilhar no XCompartilhar no FacebookCompartilhar com o Pinterest
segunda-feira, 11 de julho de 2016
sábado, 9 de julho de 2016
Did Bach Hate Pianos?
[Observação:
indicou-nos este excelente artigo Cleverson Casarin Uliana,
a quem não podemos senão agradecer.]
In the
comment section of my post “How ‘forgotten’ was Bach?”,
reader Cleverson wrote:
Speaking of Bach, you
could also write something against a myth that exists among some music
teachers, at least here in Brazil, who say that “Bach hated pianos.” They use
such a lie to discourage students from making use of specific features of the
piano as an instrument when playing Baroque repertoire.
Cleverson
also mentioned coming across the explanation that Bach played an early piano
and didn’t like that particular model, but when he came across an improved
version later, he liked what he heard.
This
“Bach hated pianos” idea intrigues me, mostly because of how Cleverson says
it’s used to dictate performance practice. I’ll share my thoughts on that in a
bit, but first I have to take care of the myth itself: Did Bach hate pianos?
Pianos
plural? No. And “hate” is probably too strong of a word to describe how he felt
about the first piano he played. I did some digging and found that Cleverson is
basically correct in the refutation of the myth. A Dresden instrument maker
named Gottfried Silbermann read an article about Bartolomeo Cristofori’s new
invention (what would become the piano), and he attempted to build one on his
own. From here, I’ll let one of Bach’s contemporaries, Johann Friedrich
Agricola, tell you what happened around the year 1736:
One of [Silbermann’s
pianofortes] was seen and played by the late Capellmeister, Mr. Joh. Sebastian
Bach. He praised, indeed, admired, its tone; but he complained that it was too
weak in the high register and too hard to play. This was taken greatly amiss by
Mr. Silbermann, who could not bear to have any fault found in his handiworks.
He was therefore angry at Mr. Bach for a long time. And yet his conscience told
him that Mr. Bach was not wrong. He therefore decided—greatly to his credit, be
it said—not to deliver any more of the instruments, but instead to think harder
about how to eliminate the faults Mr. J.S. Bach had observed.
(This
was quoted in Christoph Wolff’s Johann Sebastian Bach: The Learned
Musician on page 413.)
So,
indeed, Bach played a prototype piano and offered critical feedback on how it
felt and the sound of the upper register. This should certainly not be
interpreted as Bach dismissing every incarnation of the piano, particularly
since Bach’s exposure to the piano doesn’t end there.
As
described in Giraffes, Black Dragons, and Other Pianos: A Technological
History from Christofori to the Modern Concert Grand by Edwin M. Good,
after Silbermann incorporated Bach’s criticism into his new instruments,
Frederick the Great of Prussia was so impressed with the result that he bought
out Silbermann’s inventory, 15 pianos total. Frederick’s court harpsichordist
was none other than Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach, Johann Sebastian’s second oldest
(surviving) son. When the older Bach went to visit his son in Berlin in 1747,
Frederick was eager to show off his new pianos. He gave Bach a theme upon which
to improvise on the piano, and that later became the basis of Bach’sThe
Musical Offering. Musicologist and pianist Charles Rosen went
so far as to call a movement of The Musical Offering “the most
significant piano work of the millennium, as it is perhaps the first piece
composed for the recently invented piano -- at least, the first piece that a
composer knew would certainly be played on a piano.” Even though some of the
pianos from Frederick’s collection have survived into the 21st century,
unfortunately the exact piano played by Bach was destroyed in World War
II.
Even
more damning against the “Bach hated pianos” claim is the fact that Bach went
on to become an agent for Silbermann, selling his pianos in Leipzig. There’s
even a receipt signed by Bach on May 9, 1749, selling a “Piano et Forte” to a
Polish count, Jan Casimir von Branitzky.
So,
Bach did not hate pianos. When I asked my pianist friends,
none of them had heard the claim that he did, and I didn’t really find anything
like that on the English-speaking internet. Since I don’t speak Portuguese,
I’ll take Cleverson’s word for it that this is something that has been going
around in Brazil. So, Cleverson! I hope this is sufficient evidence for you!
As I
mentioned, what intrigues me most is how Cleverson says that the myth is used
to discourage student from playing Bach certain ways. After all, even if Bach
hated pianos (which he didn’t!), why should that even matter? It sounds like
these teachers are trying to encourage “historically informed performance,” an
approach to playing music that attempts to sound as close as possible to what
it would have sounded like when it was written.
As
sensible as historically informed performance sounds, it’s actually a hotly-debated
topic. Sound recordings didn’t exist in Bach’s era, so all we have to go on are
music notation, written descriptions, and paintings. Even those have their
limitations—the way we understand the world is fundamentally different from
18th-century perceptions, so our interpretation of notation and words is likely
not completely accurate. Still, I believe there is merit to this approach, in
that it engages the historical imagination.
The
problem comes when people claim that this purism better reflects the intent of
the composer. “Composer intent” is another much-debated topic
(seriously, musicologists will debate anything), and once again, it’s tied to
the idea that the Composer is a Great Man and an Artist-Hero. That’s more of a
19th-century construct, and Bach most likely wouldn’t have thought of his own
compositions in that way. He was very pragmatic; he made use of the instruments
he had at hand, and I doubt he would have been upset to find out that some
works he wrote for the clavichord or harpsichord were later being played on
piano. Bach didn’t expect his role as the composer to overrule logistical
factors in the realization of his works. This poses a paradox: How can we be
faithful to “composer intent” for composers from the time before “composer
intent” was a consideration?
It
reminds me of an argument I got into after giving a mid-concert lecture on
Bach’s sixth cello suite. I was speaking at a performance of the suite on
viola, and I mentioned that Bach probably wouldn’t have minded that it was
being performed on the “wrong” instrument. Afterward, a man in the audience
took issue with what I said, arguing that I should have more respect for the
fact that Bach chose to write the suite for the cello, and Bach made artistic
judgments based on the qualities of the instruments he chose. I disagreed,
pointing out some non-idiomatic writing for trumpet in the Brandenburg
concertos, and how Bach transcribed some Vivaldi string concertos for organ.
But the man was convinced that Bach was the Genius, and I was disrespecting him
when I said his music could be played on just any old instrument.
Well,
I’m a violist, so maybe I’m predisposed to being okay with transcriptions
because violists have stolen (ahem, borrowed) so much repertoire
from other instruments. As a musicologist, though, I still believe that Bach
was not persnickety about what type of instrument his music was played on. He
would probably be amused (and bemused) that we, nearly three centuries later, even
care what he thought.
Thanks
to Cleverson for the topic, and to Alejandro Planchart, Jonathan Bellman, Luke
Taylor, and Bryan Proksch for pointing me toward the right sources!
If you
have a musical myth you’d like me to check out, please let me know in the
comments, with an email to musichistorycliches@gmail.com, on my Facebook page, or via Twitter.
Sources:
Giraffes,
Black Dragons, and Other Pianos: A Technological History from Christofori to
the Modern Concert Grand by Edwin M. Good (1982)
Johann
Sebastian Bach: The Learned Musician by Christoph Wolff
(2000)
“Best
Piano Composition; Six Parts Genius” by Charles Rosen in The New York
Times (1999)
http://www.nytimes.com/1999/04/18/magazine/best-piano-composition-six-parts-genius.html
http://www.nytimes.com/1999/04/18/magazine/best-piano-composition-six-parts-genius.html
For a
thoughtful essay in defense of playing Bach on the piano, please
read this essay by harpsichordist Rosalyn Tureck: http://www.tureckbach.com/publication-documentation/page/piano-harpsichord-or-clavichord
Postado por
Carlos Nougué
às
21:00
0
comentários
Enviar por e-mailPostar no blog!Compartilhar no XCompartilhar no FacebookCompartilhar com o Pinterest
quinta-feira, 7 de julho de 2016
quarta-feira, 6 de julho de 2016
Joseph Haydn - As Sete Últimas Palavras de Cristo na Cruz
Um dos mais belos oratórios jamais escritos, e talvez a obra mais importante de Haydn.
Postado por
Carlos Nougué
às
22:21
0
comentários
Enviar por e-mailPostar no blog!Compartilhar no XCompartilhar no FacebookCompartilhar com o Pinterest
Schubert - Salve Regina D 811
Magnífico! Esta é a linha austríaca de música religiosa que vai dar em Bruckner.
Postado por
Carlos Nougué
às
13:17
0
comentários
Enviar por e-mailPostar no blog!Compartilhar no XCompartilhar no FacebookCompartilhar com o Pinterest
terça-feira, 28 de junho de 2016
segunda-feira, 20 de junho de 2016
domingo, 12 de junho de 2016
Assinar:
Postagens (Atom)
